Peer Review Process
Peer Review Process
JDSCLT implements a rigorous and transparent peer review process to ensure the scholarly quality, originality, methodological soundness, and ethical integrity of research submitted for publication.
The Journal of Digital Sharia and Contemporary Legal Thought (JDSCLT) implements a rigorous and transparent peer review process to ensure the scholarly quality, originality, methodological soundness, and ethical integrity of all research articles considered for publication.
The process is designed to provide fair, independent, and constructive evaluations while maintaining editorial accountability and academic integrity. JDSCLT adopts a double-blind peer review system, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another throughout the review process. Each manuscript that passes the initial editorial assessment is evaluated by at least two independent external reviewers with relevant academic expertise. The journal's peer review procedures are guided by the ethical principles and best practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
Submission and Initial Editorial Screening
Upon submission, manuscripts are examined by the editorial office to verify compliance with the journal's submission requirements and author guidelines. This preliminary screening includes checking manuscript completeness, required declarations, formatting, referencing, and the availability of relevant supporting documents.
Submissions may also undergo an initial similarity screening using appropriate detection tools to identify potential textual overlap or other indications of publication misconduct. Similarity reports are assessed contextually and do not, by themselves, constitute evidence of plagiarism.
Manuscripts that do not satisfy the journal's basic submission requirements may be returned to authors for technical correction before further consideration.
Initial Editorial Assessment (Desk Review)
Manuscripts that satisfy the preliminary requirements proceed to an editorial assessment conducted by the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor. At this stage, submissions are evaluated according to the following criteria:
- Relevance to the journal's aims and scope, particularly digital Sharia, Islamic law, contemporary legal thought, digital governance, and socio-legal transformation.
- Originality and significance of the proposed scholarly contribution.
- Theoretical coherence and conceptual clarity.
- Methodological appropriateness and rigor.
- Quality of legal reasoning, analytical depth, and engagement with relevant scholarship.
- Compliance with research ethics, authorship requirements, citation standards, and publication policies.
The editorial team may reject manuscripts at this stage if they fall outside the journal's scope, demonstrate insufficient scholarly merit, fail to meet essential submission requirements, or raise substantial ethical concerns.
Manuscripts requiring limited technical or formal corrections may be returned to authors for improvement before a decision is made regarding external peer review. The target period for this initial assessment is approximately two weeks from the date of submission, subject to the volume and complexity of submissions.
External Double-Blind Peer Review
Manuscripts that pass the desk review are assigned to at least two independent external reviewers. Reviewers are selected based on their demonstrated expertise in the subject matter, theoretical framework, research methodology, or relevant disciplinary fields addressed by the manuscript.
Reviewer selection considers the following criteria:
- Relevant academic and research expertise.
- Familiarity with the manuscript's subject area and methodological approach.
- Independence from the authors and their immediate research affiliations.
- Absence of actual or potential conflicts of interest that could compromise impartiality.
During the double-blind review process, identifying information about authors and reviewers is concealed to the extent reasonably possible. Authors are therefore required to submit manuscripts prepared for anonymous review, while reviewers are instructed not to seek or disclose author identities.
Reviewers are expected to evaluate manuscripts critically and constructively, considering:
- Originality and significance of the research contribution.
- Theoretical and conceptual foundations.
- Methodological rigor and appropriateness.
- Quality of evidence, analysis, and interpretation.
- Coherence of scholarly argumentation and legal reasoning.
- Engagement with relevant primary and secondary sources.
- Relevance to contemporary debates in digital Sharia and legal thought.
- Clarity, organization, and academic presentation.
The target period for external peer review is approximately three weeks. Reviewers may request additional time when necessary, and the editorial office will monitor review progress to minimize unnecessary delays.
Reviewers' Recommendations
Following their evaluation, reviewers provide written reports and recommend one of the following editorial outcomes:
Accept
The manuscript meets the journal's scholarly and editorial requirements and is suitable for publication without further substantive revision.
Accept with Minor Revisions
The manuscript requires limited corrections, clarifications, or refinements that do not substantially affect its principal argument or findings.
Major Revisions
The manuscript requires substantial improvements in its theoretical framework, methodological design, analytical development, use of evidence, or scholarly argumentation. Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers for further evaluation.
Reject
The manuscript demonstrates fundamental conceptual, methodological, scholarly, or ethical deficiencies that cannot reasonably be addressed through revision.
Reviewers' recommendations are advisory and do not constitute final editorial decisions. The handling editor evaluates the reports, considers their consistency and scholarly justification, and provides an editorial recommendation. The Editor-in-Chief retains ultimate responsibility for the final decision to accept or reject a manuscript.
Revision and Author Response
Manuscripts requiring revision are returned to the corresponding author together with the relevant reviewer reports and editorial instructions.
Authors must address reviewers' comments systematically and provide a detailed, point-by-point response explaining how each concern has been addressed. Where authors disagree with a particular recommendation, they must provide a clear scholarly justification supported by appropriate evidence or reasoning.
The indicative revision periods are:
- Minor revisions: approximately one week.
- Major revisions: approximately three weeks.
Authors may request an extension from the editorial office when additional time is reasonably required. Revised manuscripts must include a revised version of the manuscript and a response to reviewers' comments.
Submission of a revised manuscript does not guarantee acceptance. Manuscripts may undergo further review by the original reviewers, additional reviewers, or the handling editor, depending on the nature and extent of the revisions.
Editorial Evaluation and Final Decision
Following resubmission, the revised manuscript is evaluated by the handling editor and, where necessary, returned to the original reviewers to assess whether the substantive concerns raised during the initial review have been adequately addressed.
The Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor then determines the final editorial outcome. The available decisions include acceptance, a further revision request, or rejection.
A manuscript may be rejected at this stage if the revisions are insufficient, significant concerns remain unresolved, or the revised submission fails to satisfy the journal's scholarly and ethical requirements.
Final acceptance is granted only when the editorial team is satisfied that the manuscript meets the journal's standards of originality, analytical rigor, methodological integrity, ethical compliance, and relevance to its aims and scope.
Confidentiality, Conflicts of Interest, and Reviewer Ethics
All manuscripts and related review materials must be treated as confidential throughout the peer review process. Reviewers must not disclose, reproduce, distribute, or use unpublished manuscript content for personal, professional, or research purposes without appropriate authorization.
Reviewers must promptly inform the editorial office of any actual or potential conflicts of interest that could affect their impartiality. Such conflicts may include financial interests, personal relationships, institutional affiliations, supervisory relationships, or recent collaborative activities with the authors.
Reviewers must decline assignments when they lack the necessary expertise or when a conflict of interest may compromise the independence of their assessment.
Protection of Unpublished Manuscripts
Reviewers must also protect manuscript confidentiality when using digital tools. Confidential manuscripts, review reports, and substantial portions of unpublished submissions must not be uploaded to external generative AI systems or other third-party platforms where confidentiality, data protection, or intellectual property may be compromised.
All participants in the peer review process are expected to observe the relevant ethical principles established by COPE.
Copyediting, Proofreading, and Author Approval
Manuscripts that receive final acceptance proceed to copyediting and proofreading. This stage addresses linguistic accuracy, grammatical consistency, academic style, formatting, referencing, and conformity with the journal's editorial requirements.
JDSCLT uses American English academic conventions to maintain consistency in its published content. Copyediting is intended to improve the presentation and readability of accepted manuscripts without altering their substantive scholarly arguments or findings without the authors' agreement.
The typeset proofs are subsequently sent to the corresponding author for final verification. Authors are responsible for checking typographical errors, formatting, author information, affiliations, references, tables, figures, and other production details.
Any substantive changes to the accepted manuscript at the proof stage require editorial approval. Final author approval is obtained before the article proceeds to publication.
Publication
Following completion of the production process and final author approval, accepted manuscripts are published through the journal's online publishing platform in accordance with its publication schedule.
Published articles are assigned the relevant bibliographic information and Digital Object Identifier (DOI), where applicable. The journal also makes the publication record accessible to readers through its open access publishing platform.
The submission, acceptance, and publication dates are displayed in the published article to support transparency and traceability of the editorial process.
Editorial Independence and Accountability
JDSCLT maintains editorial independence throughout the peer review and publication process. Editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit, originality, methodological rigor, ethical compliance, and relevance to the journal's aims and scope, rather than commercial, institutional, or personal considerations. The journal's peer review procedures are periodically reviewed to maintain consistency with recognized publication ethics principles and evolving standards of scholarly publishing.
References and Ethical Frameworks
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). (2017). Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers. View COPE guidelines .
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ), Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association (OASPA), and World Association of Medical Editors (WAME). (2022). Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing. View transparency principles .
- Elsevier. Scopus Content Policy and Selection. View Scopus selection policy .