Research Integrity & Editorial Governance

Artificial Intelligence (AI) Tools Usage Policy

Principles and requirements governing the responsible, transparent, and accountable use of artificial intelligence in scholarly research, academic writing, peer review, and scientific publishing.

Human Accountability Transparency Research Integrity
Policy Overview

Artificial intelligence may support scholarly work, but it cannot replace human intellectual contribution, academic judgment, or responsibility for research integrity.

Human AccountabilityScholarly responsibility remains with human contributors.
TransparencyMaterial AI assistance must be appropriately disclosed.
Accuracy & VerificationAI-generated outputs require independent verification.
OriginalityAI must not replace original intellectual contributions.
ConfidentialityManuscripts and protected information must remain secure.
Research IntegrityFabrication and misrepresentation are prohibited.
01

Policy Statement and Scope

The Journal of Digital Sharia and Contemporary Legal Thought (JDSCLT) recognizes that artificial intelligence (AI), including generative AI and large language models (LLMs), is increasingly used in academic research, scholarly writing, data analysis, and publishing. The journal acknowledges that these technologies may support legitimate academic activities when used responsibly, transparently, and under meaningful human supervision.

This policy establishes the principles and requirements governing the use of AI tools by authors, editors, peer reviewers, and other contributors involved in the journal's publication process. Its primary objectives are to safeguard research integrity, ensure transparency and accountability, protect intellectual property and confidential information, and preserve the independence of scholarly judgment.

This policy applies to generative AI systems, AI-assisted writing and research tools, automated content-generation technologies, AI-based image and data-processing systems, and other comparable technologies used in the preparation, evaluation, or publication of scholarly manuscripts.

02

General Principles

All uses of AI tools in connection with manuscripts submitted to or published by JDSCLT must comply with the following principles:

  1. Human Accountability: Human authors, editors, and reviewers retain full responsibility for their respective scholarly contributions and decisions. AI tools cannot assume academic, legal, or ethical accountability.
  2. Transparency: The use of AI tools that materially contribute to manuscript content, research procedures, data analysis, or scholarly outputs must be appropriately disclosed.
  3. Accuracy and Verification: AI-generated information, references, quotations, translations, and analytical outputs must be independently verified by responsible human contributors.
  4. Originality and Intellectual Contribution: AI tools must not replace the authors' original intellectual contribution, critical reasoning, scholarly interpretation, or responsibility for research findings.
  5. Confidentiality and Data Protection: Confidential manuscripts, personal information, unpublished research data, and other protected materials must not be exposed to AI systems without appropriate authorization and safeguards.
  6. Research Integrity: AI tools must not be used to fabricate, falsify, manipulate, or misrepresent research data, evidence, references, images, or scholarly findings.
03

Acceptable Use of AI Tools by Authors

Authors may use AI tools in a limited and responsible manner to support academic work, provided that their use does not replace the authors' intellectual contribution or compromise research integrity.

Permissible Applications

  • Improving grammar, spelling, punctuation, and language clarity.
  • Assisting with translation and language refinement, subject to human verification.
  • Supporting the organization and restructuring of author-generated text.
  • Assisting with preliminary literature exploration and the identification of potentially relevant scholarly sources.
  • Supporting coding, computational procedures, and data-processing tasks.
  • Assisting with qualitative or quantitative data analysis when methodologically appropriate and transparently reported.
  • Supporting the preparation of tables, figures, diagrams, and other research-related visual materials, provided that their accuracy and integrity are verified.
  • Assisting with preliminary research organization and the development of analytical frameworks, provided that the final scholarly interpretation is independently established by the authors.

The use of AI tools for research design, data collection, coding, analysis, or other methodological procedures must be explained in the relevant methodological section of the manuscript. Authors must provide sufficient information to enable editorial assessment and, where applicable, research reproducibility.

04

Prohibited and Unacceptable Use

JDSCLT does not permit the use of AI tools in ways that undermine academic integrity, authorship accountability, or the reliability of scholarly communication.

Prohibited Practices

  1. Listing an AI system, chatbot, or other AI tool as an author or co-author.
  2. Submitting AI-generated manuscripts or substantial portions of scholarly work as original intellectual contributions without meaningful human authorship, critical evaluation, and verification.
  3. Using AI tools to fabricate, falsify, manipulate, or selectively alter research data, findings, quotations, references, or evidence.
  4. Including fabricated, inaccurate, or unverifiable citations and bibliographic information generated by AI tools.
  5. Using AI-generated content without verifying its accuracy, originality, contextual appropriateness, and source attribution.
  6. Generating or manipulating research images, figures, or visual evidence in ways that misrepresent the underlying data or research findings.
  7. Using AI tools to conceal plagiarism, duplicate publication, authorship manipulation, or other forms of publication misconduct.
  8. Uploading confidential manuscripts, unpublished research data, or identifiable personal information to AI platforms without appropriate authorization and data-protection safeguards.
  9. Misrepresenting the extent, purpose, or nature of AI assistance in a submitted manuscript.

AI-generated material must never be treated as an authoritative scholarly source. Authors must consult and cite the original, verifiable sources supporting their arguments and claims.

05

Disclosure Requirements for Authors

Authors must disclose the use of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies when such tools have materially contributed to the preparation or production of the submitted manuscript.

The disclosure must identify:

  • The name of the AI tool or system and, where available, its model or version.
  • The purpose for which the tool was used.
  • The specific aspects of the manuscript or research process supported by the tool.
  • The extent and nature of human review, verification, and editing of the AI-generated output.

The disclosure should be included in a separate section entitled Declaration of Generative AI and AI-Assisted Technologies immediately before the References section.

When AI tools are used as part of research design, data collection, data analysis, coding, or the production of research-related figures and visual materials, their use must additionally be described in the relevant section of the manuscript, particularly the Research Methodology section.

Routine spelling, grammar, punctuation, and formatting assistance provided by conventional word-processing or proofreading tools does not require a separate declaration, provided that such tools do not generate substantive scholarly content.

Authors who have not used generative AI or AI-assisted technologies in preparing their manuscripts are not required to include a declaration of non-use unless specifically requested by the editorial office.

Author Disclosure Template

Suggested Disclosure Statement

During the preparation of this manuscript, the author(s) used [name of AI tool and model, if available] for [specific purpose of use]. The author(s) subsequently reviewed, verified, and revised the relevant outputs and take full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and final content of the manuscript.

06

Authorship and Accountability

AI tools cannot be listed as authors, co-authors, or contributors with authorship status in manuscripts submitted to JDSCLT.

Authorship requires intellectual contribution, the ability to approve the final version of a manuscript, and accountability for the integrity and accuracy of the published work. AI systems cannot fulfill these responsibilities.

Authors remain fully accountable for all content submitted for publication, including material generated, translated, analyzed, or otherwise assisted by AI tools. They must ensure that the manuscript reflects their own scholarly judgment and that all sources, data, and research findings are appropriately verified and attributed.

07

Responsibilities of Peer Reviewers

Peer review is an independent scholarly activity that requires expert judgment, confidentiality, and professional accountability.

Confidentiality and Independent Assessment

Reviewers must not upload submitted manuscripts, unpublished research data, figures, tables, supplementary files, or identifiable manuscript content to external AI systems. Such practices may compromise manuscript confidentiality, intellectual property rights, and the privacy of authors and research participants.

Reviewers must not delegate manuscript evaluation, critical assessment, or the formulation of substantive peer-review recommendations to AI tools.

If reviewers use AI assistance for non-confidential language refinement or administrative purposes, they must ensure that no confidential manuscript information is disclosed and that the final review reflects their independent scholarly assessment. Any material AI assistance in preparing a review report must be disclosed to the handling editor.

Reviewers remain fully responsible for the accuracy, fairness, originality, and professional integrity of their review reports.

08

Responsibilities of Editors and the Editorial Office

Editors and editorial staff must exercise independent academic judgment and maintain the confidentiality of all manuscripts and editorial communications.

Submitted manuscripts, reviewer reports, editorial correspondence, and other confidential materials must not be uploaded to external AI systems unless the journal has explicitly authorized a secure and appropriate system under adequate confidentiality and data-protection safeguards.

AI tools may be used for limited administrative or technical support where appropriate. However, editorial decisions, including desk evaluations, reviewer selection, manuscript acceptance, revision requirements, and rejection decisions, must remain under human authority.

Editors must not rely exclusively on AI-generated assessments or automated AI-detection results to determine whether a manuscript contains misconduct or inappropriate AI use.

Editorial Authority

The Editor-in-Chief retains final authority over editorial decisions and the implementation of this policy. AI systems may provide technical assistance but cannot replace independent editorial judgment.

09

AI Detection and Research Integrity Assessment

JDSCLT may use appropriate technical and editorial procedures to examine concerns regarding undisclosed or inappropriate AI use, fabricated references, manipulated content, and other potential forms of research misconduct.

AI-detection tools may be used as preliminary screening instruments but must not constitute the sole basis for determining misconduct. The results of AI-detection systems are not conclusive evidence of AI-generated authorship or academic misconduct.

When concerns arise, the editorial office may request clarification, supporting documentation, relevant research records, or an explanation of the methods and tools used in preparing the manuscript.

Any investigation must follow the journal's Publication Ethics Statement and applicable principles of publication ethics. Authors must be given a reasonable opportunity to respond to concerns before an editorial determination is made.

10

Violations and Editorial Actions

Failure to comply with this policy may result in appropriate editorial action, depending on the nature, severity, and publication stage of the violation.

Possible actions include:

  • Requesting clarification or additional disclosure from the authors.
  • Requiring corrections or revisions to the submitted manuscript.
  • Rejecting a manuscript when serious violations are established before publication.
  • Initiating a research integrity investigation in cases involving suspected fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, or deliberate misrepresentation.
  • Publishing a correction, expression of concern, or retraction when a violation is identified after publication, in accordance with the journal's relevant policies.

Editorial actions must be proportionate to the seriousness of the violation and consistent with established publication ethics procedures.

11

Policy Review and Updates

JDSCLT recognizes that AI technologies, research practices, and international publication ethics standards continue to evolve. Accordingly, this policy will be reviewed periodically and revised when necessary to reflect developments in scholarly publishing, research integrity, and responsible AI governance.

The journal's current published version of this policy shall serve as the authoritative reference for authors, reviewers, editors, and other contributors.

References and Ethical Frameworks

  1. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Authorship and AI Tools: COPE Position Statement.
    https://doi.org/10.24318/cCVRZBms
  2. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals. Particularly Section V: Use of Artificial Intelligence in Publishing.
    ICMJE Recommendations
  3. World Association of Medical Editors (WAME). Chatbots, Generative AI, and Scholarly Manuscripts: WAME Recommendations on Chatbots and Generative Artificial Intelligence in Relation to Scholarly Publications.
    https://doi.org/10.1080/03007995.2023.2286102
  4. Scopus. Content Policy and Selection.
    Scopus Content Policy and Selection
  5. Elsevier. Generative AI Policies for Journals.
    Elsevier Generative AI Policies
Research Integrity & Publication EthicsJDSCLT | AI Governance