Publication Ethics / Editorial Policies

Article Withdrawal, Retraction, Removal, and Republication Policy

Editorial procedures for maintaining the integrity of scholarly publications through transparent decisions on manuscript withdrawal, article retraction, exceptional removal, and republication of corrected scholarly work.

Journal JDSCLT
Policy Area Publication Integrity
Authority Editor-in-Chief
Editorial Commitment

The Journal of Digital Sharia and Contemporary Legal Thought (JDSCLT) is committed to maintaining the integrity, transparency, and reliability of the scholarly record. Editorial actions concerning published and unpublished manuscripts are governed by documented evidence, procedural fairness, and established principles of publication ethics.

01 Withdrawal Before formal publication
02 Retraction Published scholarly record
03 Removal Exceptional legal or ethical cases
04 Republication Corrected scholarly version
01

General Principles

The Journal of Digital Sharia and Contemporary Legal Thought (JDSCLT) is committed to maintaining the integrity, transparency, and reliability of the scholarly record. The journal recognizes that, in exceptional circumstances, manuscripts or published articles may require withdrawal, retraction, removal, or republication to address substantial errors, breaches of publication ethics, or legal and ethical concerns.

This policy is guided by the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the National Information Standards Organization (NISO) Recommended Practice on the Communication of Retractions, Removals, and Expressions of Concern (CREC), and relevant scholarly publishing standards.

Editorial decisions concerning withdrawal, retraction, removal, and republication are made independently, based on documented evidence, procedural fairness, and the seriousness of the issues identified. Authors will ordinarily be given an opportunity to respond to concerns before a final decision is made, except where immediate action is necessary to protect the scholarly record or prevent significant harm.

Publication status matters. The journal distinguishes between the withdrawal of manuscripts that have not been formally published and post-publication actions involving articles that have become part of the scholarly record.

02

Withdrawal of Manuscripts Before Publication

Manuscript withdrawal applies to submissions that have been accepted or are undergoing editorial processing but have not yet been formally published as part of the journal's scholarly record.

A manuscript may be considered for withdrawal under the following circumstances:

  • The authors identify substantial errors in the manuscript that cannot adequately be addressed through ordinary revision.
  • The manuscript has been submitted simultaneously to another journal or has been published elsewhere in violation of the journal's submission requirements.
  • There is credible evidence of plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabricated or manipulated data, or other forms of publication misconduct.
  • The authorship declaration contains false or misleading information, including the unauthorized inclusion or exclusion of individuals.
  • Other circumstances raise substantial concerns regarding the manuscript's compliance with the journal's publication ethics.

Authors requesting withdrawal must submit a formal written request to the editorial office, explaining the reasons for withdrawal and confirming that all co-authors have agreed to the request. The editorial office may request supporting documentation where necessary.

A withdrawal request submitted after acceptance does not automatically terminate the editorial process. The Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editorial representative will assess the request and determine whether withdrawal is justified.

If a manuscript is withdrawn before formal publication, its content will not be published. If an accepted manuscript or article in press has already been made publicly accessible, the journal may replace its public content with a withdrawal notice, while retaining the relevant bibliographic and editorial records where appropriate.

The withdrawal notice will identify the manuscript, state that it has been withdrawn, and provide a brief explanation where disclosure is appropriate. The notice will not disclose confidential information or make unsubstantiated allegations.

03

Retraction of Published Articles

Retraction applies to articles that have been formally published and have become part of the scholarly record, including articles published online before assignment to a specific volume or issue.

A published article may be retracted when there is clear evidence that its findings, conclusions, or scholarly integrity are substantially unreliable, or when serious violations of publication ethics have occurred. Grounds for retraction may include, but are not limited to:

  • Plagiarism, substantial unattributed reproduction, or duplicate publication.
  • Fabrication, falsification, or manipulation of research data, evidence, or sources.
  • Serious authorship misconduct, including false attribution or the unauthorized inclusion or exclusion of authors.
  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest that materially compromise the integrity or interpretation of the research.
  • Serious ethical violations involving research participants, data, or research procedures.
  • Substantial errors that invalidate the principal findings, arguments, or conclusions of the article.
  • Other forms of misconduct or ethical breaches that undermine the reliability or integrity of the scholarly record.

Retraction may be initiated by the authors, the Editor-in-Chief, the Editorial Board, the publisher, or other parties who provide credible evidence of a potential problem. Requests or allegations will be assessed independently, and the journal may consult relevant institutions, independent experts, or other appropriate parties where necessary.

The journal follows these procedures when issuing a retraction:

  1. The editorial office conducts an initial assessment of the concerns and determines whether further investigation is necessary.
  2. The authors concerned are ordinarily invited to provide an explanation and relevant supporting evidence.
  3. Where appropriate, the journal may consult independent experts or the authors' affiliated institutions.
  4. The Editor-in-Chief makes the final editorial decision based on the available evidence and the seriousness of the identified issues.
  5. A formal retraction notice is published as soon as reasonably practicable following the decision.

The retraction notice will:

  • Be clearly titled "Retraction: [Original Article Title]."
  • Identify the original article through its title, authors, publication details, and DOI.
  • Explain the reason for retraction in sufficient detail to enable readers to understand the basis for the decision.
  • Identify whether the retraction was initiated by the authors, the journal, or another relevant party, where disclosure is appropriate.
  • Be linked directly to the original article and published as a separate, identifiable notice.
  • Be made freely accessible and included in the journal's relevant publication records.
Preservation of the Scholarly Record

The original article will ordinarily remain accessible to preserve the scholarly record. Its status will be clearly identified as RETRACTED, and the PDF will carry a visible retraction watermark on each page.

The HTML version, where available, will display a prominent retraction notice and a direct link to the formal retraction statement.

The journal will update the relevant DOI and publication metadata, where technically applicable, to ensure that the retracted status is communicated to indexing services, repositories, and other scholarly information systems.

04

Expression of Concern

An Expression of Concern may be issued when credible allegations or evidence raise serious questions about the reliability, integrity, or ethical compliance of a published article, but the available information is insufficient to justify an immediate retraction.

An Expression of Concern may be considered when:

  • An investigation into suspected research or publication misconduct is ongoing.
  • Relevant institutions or authorities have not yet completed their investigations.
  • The evidence available to the journal is inconclusive but raises substantial concerns.
  • Delays in obtaining necessary information prevent the journal from reaching a definitive editorial decision.

An Expression of Concern will be published as a separate editorial notice, linked directly to the article concerned. It will explain the nature of the concern without prejudging the outcome of an ongoing investigation.

The journal will review the status of the Expression of Concern when additional evidence becomes available. Depending on the findings, the journal may subsequently issue a correction, maintain the notice, or proceed with retraction.

Important distinction. An Expression of Concern is not equivalent to a retraction and does not, by itself, establish that misconduct has occurred.

05

Article Removal in Exceptional Circumstances

Article removal is an exceptional measure reserved for circumstances in which continued public availability of the full text would create serious legal, ethical, privacy, or safety concerns.

Removal may be considered when:

  • The published content is defamatory or infringes legally protected rights.
  • The article contains confidential or personally identifiable information published without appropriate authorization.
  • A competent court or relevant legal authority requires the removal of the content.
  • The article violates applicable laws or regulations.
  • Continued access to the content would create a demonstrable and serious risk to individuals, institutions, or the public.

Removal will not ordinarily be used as a substitute for retraction, nor solely because an article contains errors or attracts scholarly disagreement.

Where removal is deemed necessary, the journal will retain a bibliographic record of the article to the extent legally permissible. The original full text will be replaced by a removal notice explaining, in general terms, why the content is no longer available.

The notice will preserve relevant bibliographic information, including the article title, author information, original publication details, and DOI, where disclosure is legally permissible.

The journal will document the reasons for removal and retain relevant editorial records. Where appropriate, the journal will also communicate the change to relevant indexing services and DOI registration agencies.

06

Retraction and Republication

In exceptional circumstances, an article that has been retracted because of substantial errors may be considered for republication following a comprehensive correction and reassessment.

Republication may be considered when:

  • The identified errors can be adequately corrected through substantial revision.
  • The corrected version provides a reliable and transparent account of the research or scholarly argument.
  • The authors provide a detailed explanation of the changes and their implications.
  • The revised manuscript undergoes an appropriate editorial assessment and, where necessary, a new round of independent peer review.

Republication is not automatic and remains subject to the journal's editorial assessment and publication requirements.

Where republication is approved, the original article will retain its retracted status and remain linked to the retraction notice. The corrected version will be published as a separately identifiable publication and will include a clear reference to the original article and its retraction.

The relationship between both versions will be transparently documented through their respective publication records and DOI metadata, where applicable.

Publication Transparency

The republication notice will explain the reasons for republication, identify the substantive corrections made, and provide links to the original retracted article and the corrected version.

07

Editorial Authority, Documentation, and Notification

The Editor-in-Chief has ultimate responsibility for editorial decisions concerning manuscript withdrawal, article retraction, article removal, Expressions of Concern, and republication. These decisions may be informed by recommendations from handling editors, members of the Editorial Board, independent experts, or relevant institutional authorities.

All cases will be handled with due regard for confidentiality, impartiality, procedural fairness, and the right of concerned parties to respond. The journal will maintain appropriate records of allegations, investigations, correspondence, evidence, editorial deliberations, and final decisions.

Authors will ordinarily be notified of decisions affecting their manuscripts or published articles. Where necessary, the journal may also notify relevant institutions, publishers, indexing services, DOI registration agencies, or other parties responsible for maintaining the scholarly record.

The journal will not treat a disagreement with an article's interpretation, theoretical position, or scholarly conclusions as sufficient grounds for withdrawal or retraction. Editorial action must be based on substantiated concerns involving reliability, publication ethics, legal obligations, or other legitimate grounds established under this policy.

This policy applies to all manuscripts and published articles submitted to or published by JDSCLT, regardless of publication date. The journal reserves the right to review and update this policy in response to developments in scholarly publishing standards and publication ethics.

References

Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). (2025). COPE Retraction Guidelines (Version 3).
https://doi.org/10.24318/cope.2019.1.4
National Information Standards Organization (NISO). (2024). NISO RP-45-2024: Communication of Retractions, Removals, and Expressions of Concern (CREC).
https://doi.org/10.3789/niso-rp-45-2024
Crossref. (n.d.). Version control, corrections, and retractions.
Crossref Documentation