Conflicts of Interest Policy
Conflicts of Interest Policy
Principles and procedures for identifying, disclosing, assessing, and managing competing interests throughout the scholarly publication process.
Transparent disclosure and appropriate management of competing interests are essential to preserving impartial scholarly judgment and the credibility of academic publishing.
Policy Statement
The Journal of Digital Sharia and Contemporary Legal Thought (JDSCLT) is committed to maintaining transparency, academic integrity, and editorial independence throughout the scholarly publication process. The journal recognizes that conflicts of interest may arise from financial, personal, professional, institutional, academic, political, religious, or other relationships and activities that could influence, or reasonably be perceived to influence, scholarly judgment.
This policy establishes the principles and procedures for identifying, disclosing, assessing, and managing actual, potential, and perceived conflicts of interest involving authors, peer reviewers, editors, editorial board members, the journal, and its publisher.
All individuals involved in the submission, evaluation, editorial decision-making, and publication processes are expected to disclose relevant interests in a timely and transparent manner. The existence of a conflict of interest does not necessarily constitute misconduct. However, failure to disclose a relevant conflict or failure to manage it appropriately may compromise the integrity and credibility of scholarly communication.
Definition and Scope of Conflicts of Interest
A conflict of interest, also referred to as a competing interest, occurs when an individual's or organization's personal, financial, professional, institutional, or other interests could interfere with, or reasonably be perceived as interfering with, the objective conduct, evaluation, reporting, or publication of scholarly research.
Conflicts of interest may be actual, potential, or perceived. Their significance must be assessed in relation to the manuscript and the responsibilities of the individuals involved.
- Actual conflicts of interest: Circumstances in which an existing relationship or interest directly compromises, or has a demonstrable influence on, an individual's professional or editorial judgment.
- Potential conflicts of interest: Circumstances in which an existing relationship or interest could reasonably develop into a conflict that may affect future scholarly or editorial responsibilities.
- Perceived conflicts of interest: Circumstances in which an external observer could reasonably question an individual's impartiality, even when no actual bias or inappropriate influence has occurred.
The journal assesses conflicts of interest based on their relevance to the manuscript and the responsibilities of the individuals involved. The disclosure of an interest does not automatically disqualify an individual from participating in the publication process. Appropriate management measures will be determined according to the nature and significance of the disclosed interest.
Types of Conflicts of Interest
JDSCLT recognizes several categories of competing interests, including but not limited to the following:
3.1. Financial Conflicts of Interest
- Employment, consultancy, or paid professional relationships.
- Research grants, honoraria, speaker fees, or other financial support.
- Ownership of shares, stocks, or other financial interests in relevant organizations.
- Patents, royalties, intellectual property rights, or commercial interests.
- Financial relationships with organizations that may benefit from the publication of a manuscript.
3.2. Personal and Professional Conflicts of Interest
- Family relationships, close personal relationships, or other significant personal associations.
- Current or recent supervisory, mentoring, or academic relationships.
- Professional collaborations or joint research projects.
- Personal disputes, professional rivalries, or relationships that may compromise impartial judgment.
3.3. Academic and Institutional Conflicts of Interest
- Employment or institutional affiliations shared by authors, reviewers, or editors where these relationships could compromise independent assessment.
- Recent co-authorship or research collaboration.
- Academic competition involving substantially overlapping research.
- Institutional interests that may benefit from the acceptance, rejection, or interpretation of particular research findings.
- Supervisory or evaluative relationships between individuals involved in a manuscript.
3.4. Political, Religious, and Ideological Conflicts of Interest
Given the interdisciplinary focus of JDSCLT, conflicts may also arise from political, religious, or ideological commitments that could reasonably affect the impartial evaluation or presentation of scholarly arguments.
Such commitments do not automatically constitute disqualifying conflicts. However, individuals must disclose relevant interests when they could reasonably compromise, or be perceived as compromising, their academic judgment.
3.5. Institutional and Organizational Conflicts of Interest
Institutional conflicts may arise when an organization, institution, or other entity has financial, reputational, political, or strategic interests that could influence research activities, editorial evaluation, or publication decisions.
Responsibilities of Authors
Authors are responsible for disclosing all financial and non-financial interests that could influence, or reasonably be perceived as influencing, their research, interpretation of findings, or manuscript preparation.
- Disclose relevant financial and non-financial relationships at the time of manuscript submission.
- Identify funding sources, institutional support, sponsorships, and other relevant financial relationships associated with the research.
- Explain the role of funders or sponsors, where applicable, in research design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, manuscript preparation, and the decision to submit the manuscript.
- Declare relevant personal, professional, academic, or institutional interests that may affect the objectivity of the research.
- Include a clear Conflict of Interest Statement in the submitted manuscript.
- Notify the editorial office of any relevant conflict of interest that becomes apparent after submission or publication.
No Conflicting Interests
Declaration of Conflicting Interests: The authors declare that they have no known competing financial or non-financial interests that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this manuscript.
If a conflict exists, authors must provide a clear description of its nature and its potential relevance to the submitted research. The editorial office may request additional information or clarification when necessary.
Responsibilities of Peer Reviewers
Peer reviewers must evaluate manuscripts objectively, independently, and confidentially. Before accepting an invitation to review, reviewers must assess whether any personal, financial, professional, institutional, or academic relationships could compromise, or reasonably be perceived as compromising, their impartiality.
Reviewer Disclosure and Recusal
Reviewers must:
- Disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest to the handling editor before accepting a review assignment.
- Decline the invitation when a significant conflict could compromise their independent assessment.
- Inform the editor immediately if a previously undisclosed conflict becomes apparent during the review process.
- Avoid using unpublished information obtained through peer review for personal, professional, or academic advantage.
- Maintain the confidentiality and independence of the peer-review process.
Potential conflicts may include, but are not limited to, current employment at the same institution as an author, recent supervisory or mentoring relationships, recent research collaborations, joint grant participation, close personal relationships, or direct academic competition involving substantially overlapping research.
As an illustrative reference, recent collaborations or supervisory relationships within the preceding three years may warrant particular scrutiny. However, the existence and significance of a conflict must be assessed in context rather than determined solely by a fixed time period.
When a significant conflict is identified, the reviewer must decline the assignment or withdraw from the review process. The handling editor will arrange an alternative independent reviewer where necessary.
Responsibilities of Editors and Editorial Board Members
Editors and editorial board members must maintain impartiality, professional independence, and transparency in all editorial activities.
Editors must disclose relevant personal, financial, professional, academic, or institutional interests that could compromise their editorial judgment. They must not participate in editorial decisions concerning manuscripts in which they have an actual, potential, or significant perceived conflict of interest.
When a conflict is identified, the editor must:
- Disclose the conflict to the Editor-in-Chief or another authorized editorial authority.
- Withdraw from manuscript evaluation, reviewer selection, editorial discussions, and publication decisions relating to the affected submission.
- Ensure that the manuscript is reassigned to an independent editor who has no relevant conflict.
- Refrain from accessing confidential editorial information beyond what is necessary for legitimate administrative responsibilities.
Manuscripts Submitted by Editors and Editorial Board Members
Manuscripts submitted by the Editor-in-Chief, handling editors, editorial board members, or other individuals involved in editorial decision-making must undergo the same scholarly evaluation and peer-review standards as other submissions.
The author-editor must not participate in any editorial decision concerning their own manuscript. An independent editor without relevant personal, institutional, professional, or academic conflicts must manage the submission, including reviewer selection, assessment, and the final recommendation.
Where necessary, the journal may appoint an external independent editor to safeguard the integrity and impartiality of the evaluation process.
Responsibilities of the Journal and Publisher
JDSCLT and its publisher, CV Zamzami Scholar Publishing, recognize the importance of maintaining a clear separation between publishing operations, commercial interests, and academic editorial decision-making.
The publisher is responsible for the journal's publishing infrastructure, administrative operations, and institutional support. However, manuscript evaluation, peer-review procedures, and academic publication decisions remain under the independent authority of the Editor-in-Chief and the Editorial Board.
The publisher and journal management must ensure that:
- Financial, commercial, organizational, or personal interests do not interfere with editorial decisions.
- Publication fees, financial arrangements, or other commercial considerations do not determine manuscript acceptance or rejection.
- Editors are not compensated on the basis of the number or proportion of manuscripts accepted for publication.
- Editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit, methodological rigor, originality, relevance, and compliance with publication ethics.
- Any institutional or organizational interests that could reasonably affect editorial independence are appropriately disclosed and managed.
Academic Authority and Publishing Operations
The Editor-in-Chief retains final academic authority over manuscript acceptance, revision, or rejection, subject to the journal's established editorial procedures and publication ethics policies.
Disclosure and Management Procedures
JDSCLT requires relevant conflicts of interest to be disclosed at the appropriate stages of the publication process.
8.1. Disclosure by Authors
Authors must disclose relevant competing interests during manuscript submission and include an appropriate statement in the manuscript. The editorial office may request additional information or supporting documentation when necessary.
8.2. Disclosure by Peer Reviewers
Reviewers must disclose relevant conflicts when responding to an invitation to review and before accessing or evaluating the manuscript. If a conflict becomes apparent after the review has commenced, the reviewer must notify the handling editor immediately.
8.3. Disclosure by Editors
Editors and editorial board members must disclose relevant interests before undertaking editorial responsibilities involving a particular manuscript. When a conflict is identified, the manuscript must be reassigned to an independent editor.
8.4. Assessment and Management
The Editor-in-Chief or an authorized independent editor is responsible for assessing disclosed conflicts and determining appropriate management measures.
Depending on the circumstances, these measures may include:
- Requiring additional disclosure from the relevant individual.
- Reassigning a manuscript to an independent editor.
- Replacing a conflicted peer reviewer.
- Restricting access to confidential editorial information.
- Publishing a disclosure statement where appropriate.
- Requesting institutional clarification or investigation when necessary.
The journal will maintain appropriate records of disclosures and the actions taken to manage relevant conflicts.
Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest and Editorial Actions
If a potential conflict of interest is identified after manuscript submission, during peer review, or following publication, the journal will assess the matter in accordance with its publication ethics procedures.
The editorial office may request clarification from the individuals concerned and, where necessary, seek additional information from relevant institutions or organizations.
Depending on the seriousness and implications of the matter, possible editorial actions include:
- Requesting a formal disclosure or clarification.
- Reassigning the manuscript to an independent editor or reviewer.
- Suspending the editorial process while the matter is examined.
- Requiring a correction or additional disclosure before publication.
- Publishing a correction, expression of concern, or retraction when a previously undisclosed conflict has materially affected the integrity of the published record.
- Referring the matter to an appropriate institution or authority when further investigation is warranted.
All actions will be proportionate to the nature and significance of the conflict and consistent with the journal's Publication Ethics Statement and applicable publication ethics standards.
The individuals concerned will be given a reasonable opportunity to provide an explanation before an editorial determination is made, except where immediate protective action is necessary to safeguard the integrity of the publication process.
Post-Publication Disclosure and Transparency
When a relevant conflict of interest is identified after publication, JDSCLT will assess whether the published article requires additional disclosure or correction.
Where the omission or misrepresentation materially affects the transparency, interpretation, or integrity of the published research, the journal may publish a correction, expression of concern, or retraction in accordance with its Article Withdrawal, Retraction, Removal, and Republication Policy.
The journal aims to preserve the accuracy, transparency, and reliability of the scholarly record while protecting the rights and legitimate interests of all parties involved.
Policy Review and Updates
JDSCLT recognizes that standards concerning conflicts of interest and scholarly publishing continue to evolve. This policy will therefore be reviewed periodically and revised when necessary to reflect developments in publication ethics, editorial governance, and international scholarly publishing standards.
All authors, reviewers, editors, editorial board members, and other contributors involved in the journal's publication process are expected to comply with the current published version of this policy.
References and Ethical Frameworks
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ), Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association (OASPA), and World Association of Medical Editors (WAME). (2026). Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, Version 5.0.
https://doi.org/10.24318/cope.2019.1.12 - Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). COPE Core Practices: Conflicts of Interest/Competing Interests.
COPE Core Practices - International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals: Author Responsibilities, Disclosure of Financial and Non-Financial Relationships and Activities, and Conflicts of Interest.
ICMJE Recommendations - Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.
https://doi.org/10.24318/cope.2019.1.9 - Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Code of Conduct and Best Practice Guidelines for Journal Editors.
COPE Editorial Guidelines