Journal Policies / Editorial Standards

Publication Ethics Statement

The Journal of Digital Sharia and Contemporary Legal Thought (JDSCLT) is committed to upholding scholarly integrity, editorial independence, research accountability, and responsible academic publishing.

Research Integrity   ·   Editorial Responsibility   ·   Publication Standards

Publication ethics are fundamental to the credibility, transparency, and intellectual integrity of scholarly communication. JDSCLT expects all participants in the publication process, including authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher, to uphold the highest standards of academic conduct.

This statement establishes the ethical principles and responsibilities governing manuscript submission, editorial assessment, peer review, publication decisions, and post-publication accountability. The journal's policies are guided by the core principles and best-practice recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

01

Ethical Principles and Editorial Commitment

JDSCLT is committed to the principles of honesty, transparency, accountability, fairness, and academic independence throughout the publication process. The journal seeks to ensure that scholarly contributions are evaluated on the basis of their intellectual quality, methodological rigor, originality, and relevance to the journal's aims and scope.

All parties involved in scholarly publishing are expected to act responsibly and in accordance with established standards of research integrity. Editorial decisions must remain independent of personal interests, institutional pressure, commercial considerations, and other forms of inappropriate influence.

JDSCLT follows the relevant principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), particularly those concerning editorial responsibilities, peer-review integrity, research misconduct, corrections, and retractions.

02

Duties and Responsibilities of Editors

Editors are responsible for maintaining the academic quality, integrity, and fairness of the journal's editorial process. Editorial decisions must be based on scholarly merit, originality, methodological soundness, and relevance to the journal's scope.

Editors are expected to:

  • Evaluate manuscripts objectively and without discrimination based on authors' institutional affiliations, nationality, gender, religious background, or personal characteristics.
  • Ensure that manuscripts undergo an appropriate and independent peer-review process before publication decisions are made.
  • Maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and editorial communications.
  • Identify and manage potential conflicts of interest that may compromise editorial impartiality.
  • Select reviewers whose expertise is relevant to the subject matter and methodological orientation of the manuscript.
  • Respond appropriately to allegations of plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, authorship disputes, and other forms of publication misconduct.
  • Ensure that corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions are considered when substantial errors or ethical violations are identified.

Editors must not use unpublished information obtained through manuscript evaluation for personal research or professional advantage without the authors' explicit permission.

03

Duties and Responsibilities of Authors

Authors are responsible for ensuring that their manuscripts represent original, accurate, and ethically conducted scholarly work. Submission to JDSCLT indicates that the manuscript is not under consideration by another journal and has not been published previously in substantially the same form, except where prior dissemination has been explicitly permitted and disclosed.

Authors are required to:

  • Present research findings accurately and provide sufficient methodological information to support scholarly evaluation.
  • Ensure that all sources, ideas, data, and materials derived from other works are appropriately acknowledged and cited.
  • Avoid plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, and inappropriate text recycling.
  • Obtain appropriate ethical approval and informed consent where required by the nature of the research.
  • Disclose relevant funding sources and potential conflicts of interest.
  • Ensure that all listed authors have made meaningful scholarly contributions and have approved the submitted manuscript.
  • Cooperate with editorial requests for clarification, supporting documentation, corrections, or responses to ethical concerns.

Authors remain responsible for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of their submitted work, including any material produced or revised with the assistance of digital tools or artificial intelligence.

04

Duties and Responsibilities of Peer Reviewers

Peer reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the scholarly quality and credibility of JDSCLT. Reviews should provide constructive, evidence-based, and impartial assessments of the manuscripts under consideration.

Reviewers are expected to:

  • Assess manuscripts objectively, focusing on originality, theoretical contribution, methodological rigor, argumentation, and relevance to the journal's scope.
  • Identify relevant scholarly works that have not been adequately acknowledged.
  • Inform the editor of any substantial similarity between the manuscript and other published or submitted works.
  • Decline review assignments when they lack the necessary expertise or have conflicts of interest that may compromise impartiality.
  • Maintain strict confidentiality and refrain from sharing, reproducing, or using unpublished manuscript content.
  • Submit reviews within the agreed timeframe and communicate any potential delay to the editorial office.

Reviewers must not contact authors directly regarding a manuscript unless explicitly authorized by the editorial team.

05

Publisher Responsibilities

CV Zamzami Scholar Publishing, as the publisher of JDSCLT, is committed to supporting the journal's editorial independence and maintaining an ethical and transparent publishing environment.

The publisher is responsible for:

  • Providing the administrative and technical support necessary for the journal's editorial and publishing operations.
  • Respecting editorial independence and ensuring that publication decisions are not determined by commercial or non-academic interests.
  • Supporting the preservation, accessibility, and integrity of published scholarly content.
  • Cooperating with editors in addressing allegations of publication misconduct and other ethical concerns.
  • Maintaining transparent publication policies and making relevant journal information publicly accessible.
06

Authorship and Contributorship

Authorship must reflect substantial intellectual contributions to the research and manuscript. Individuals should not be listed as authors solely because of their institutional position, administrative authority, financial support, or supervisory status.

All authors must have made meaningful contributions to the conception or design of the research, the acquisition or analysis of data, the interpretation of findings, or the development of the manuscript. They must also participate in reviewing or revising the work, approve the final version, and accept accountability for their contributions.

The corresponding author is responsible for communicating with the editorial office, confirming that all authors have approved the submission, and ensuring that authorship information is accurate and complete.

Any proposed change in authorship, including the addition, removal, or rearrangement of authors, must be communicated to the editor with written agreement from all affected authors before the change is considered.

Contributions that do not meet authorship criteria should be acknowledged appropriately where relevant.

07

Conflicts of Interest

A conflict of interest arises when personal, professional, financial, institutional, or other relationships may reasonably be perceived to influence scholarly judgment or editorial decision-making.

Authors must disclose relevant financial and non-financial interests that could influence the research, its interpretation, or its publication. Reviewers must decline assignments when an existing relationship or competing interest could compromise their impartiality.

Editors must recuse themselves from handling manuscripts when they have a personal, professional, collaborative, or financial relationship that may affect their independent judgment. Such manuscripts should be assigned to another qualified editor.

All relevant conflicts of interest should be disclosed transparently. The existence of a disclosed conflict does not necessarily prevent publication, provided that it can be appropriately assessed and managed.

08

Research Ethics and Data Integrity

JDSCLT expects all submitted research to comply with applicable ethical standards and relevant institutional or legal requirements. Authors are responsible for ensuring that their research has been conducted with appropriate regard for research participants, communities, sources, and research materials.

Research involving human participants, interviews, surveys, personal information, or other sensitive materials should obtain appropriate ethical approval where required. Authors must ensure that informed consent, privacy, confidentiality, and participant protection have been addressed.

Authors must report research methods and findings accurately. Data fabrication, falsification, manipulation of evidence, and misleading presentation of research results constitute serious violations of research integrity.

Where relevant, authors may be asked to provide supporting documentation, research instruments, or additional information necessary to clarify the integrity and reliability of the submitted work, subject to legitimate confidentiality and ethical restrictions.

09

Plagiarism and Publication Misconduct

JDSCLT does not tolerate plagiarism or other forms of publication misconduct. All manuscripts must demonstrate originality, appropriate attribution, and responsible engagement with existing scholarship.

Publication misconduct may include, but is not limited to:

  • Plagiarism, including the unattributed use of another person's words, ideas, arguments, or research findings.
  • Data fabrication or falsification.
  • Duplicate or redundant publication.
  • Inappropriate text recycling without adequate disclosure or justification.
  • Citation manipulation or practices intended to distort scholarly impact.
  • Gift authorship, ghost authorship, or other forms of authorship misrepresentation.
  • Undisclosed manipulation of images, data, or research materials.

Manuscripts may be screened for textual similarity and examined for other indicators of potential misconduct. Similarity results are considered in context and do not, by themselves, establish plagiarism.

When concerns arise, the editorial team will assess the available evidence and may request an explanation or supporting documentation from the authors. Appropriate action will be taken in accordance with the seriousness of the concern and relevant publication ethics guidance.

10

Artificial Intelligence and AI-Assisted Technologies

JDSCLT recognizes that artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-assisted technologies are increasingly used in research, academic writing, data analysis, and scholarly communication. Their use must remain transparent, accountable, and consistent with established principles of research integrity.

Responsible Use of AI

Authors, Editors, and Reviewers

AI cannot be listed as an author. Authorship requires human accountability, intellectual responsibility, and the ability to approve and defend the published work.

Disclosure by authors. Authors must disclose substantive use of generative AI or AI-assisted technologies in the preparation of the manuscript, particularly when such tools contribute to content generation, analytical interpretation, data processing, or the development of scholarly arguments.

Human responsibility. Authors remain fully responsible for verifying the accuracy, originality, validity, and integrity of all AI-assisted content, including references, quotations, data, and interpretations.

Routine language assistance. Basic spelling, grammar, and punctuation correction generally does not require a separate declaration when it does not materially alter the intellectual content of the manuscript.

Editorial confidentiality. Editors and reviewers must protect the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and review materials. They must not upload confidential content to external AI systems where confidentiality, data protection, or intellectual property may be compromised.

Undisclosed or inappropriate use of AI that compromises originality, accuracy, research integrity, or the confidentiality of the editorial process may be treated as an ethical concern and assessed accordingly.

11

Allegations of Misconduct, Complaints, and Appeals

JDSCLT takes allegations of research and publication misconduct seriously. Complaints concerning editorial decisions, peer-review procedures, authorship, plagiarism, conflicts of interest, or other ethical matters may be submitted to the editorial office.

All allegations will be considered carefully, fairly, and confidentially to the extent possible. The editorial team may request relevant information, supporting evidence, or clarification from the parties involved before determining an appropriate response.

Authors may submit an appeal when they believe that an editorial decision resulted from a significant factual misunderstanding, procedural irregularity, or an error in the assessment of the manuscript. Appeals must provide clear and substantive reasons rather than merely expressing disagreement with the outcome.

Where necessary, the editor may seek independent advice from qualified individuals who are not directly involved in the original decision. Decisions concerning complaints and appeals should be documented appropriately.

12

Corrections, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern

JDSCLT is committed to preserving the accuracy and reliability of the scholarly record. When significant errors or ethical concerns are identified in published material, the journal will consider appropriate post-publication action.

Depending on the nature and severity of the issue, the journal may issue:

  • Correction: to address errors that affect the accuracy or clarity of a published article but do not invalidate its principal findings or conclusions.
  • Retraction: when substantial errors, unreliable findings, serious ethical violations, or other circumstances undermine the integrity of the published work.
  • Expression of concern: when credible concerns have arisen but an investigation has not yet reached a conclusive outcome.

Decisions to issue corrections, retractions, or expressions of concern will be made by the editorial team after considering the available evidence and relevant publication ethics guidance.

Such notices should clearly identify the affected publication and explain the reason for the editorial action. The journal aims to maintain an accurate and transparent scholarly record.

13

Open Access and Copyright Policy

JDSCLT provides immediate open access to its published content in accordance with the principle that making scholarly research freely available supports the global exchange of knowledge.

Published articles are distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, unless otherwise stated in the relevant publication record.

Under this license, users may share and adapt published material for noncommercial purposes, provided that appropriate credit is given, a link to the license is supplied, and changes, if any, are indicated. Commercial use is not permitted under this license.

Authors retain copyright in their published work, subject to the publication agreement and the journal's right of first publication. Authors are responsible for ensuring that they have the necessary rights and permissions for all third-party materials included in their manuscripts.

References and Ethical Frameworks

  1. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). COPE Core Practices. https://publicationethics.org/core-practices .
  2. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing. https://doi.org/10.24318/cope.2019.1.12 .
  3. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Authorship and AI Tools. https://doi.org/10.24318/cCVRZBms .
  4. World Association of Medical Editors (WAME). Recommendations on Chatbots and Generative Artificial Intelligence in Relation to Scholarly Publications. https://doi.org/10.1080/03007995.2023.2286102 .

Journal of Digital Sharia and Contemporary Legal Thought (JDSCLT)
Published by CV Zamzami Scholar Publishing. This statement applies to all participants involved in the journal's editorial and publication processes.