RESEARCH INTEGRITY · EDITORIAL POLICY

Research Data and Data Availability Policy

Advancing research transparency, methodological accountability, and responsible data stewardship in digital Islamic scholarship.

JOURNAL OF INDONESIAN DIGITAL ISLAMIC STUDIES
OUR RESEARCH DATA COMMITMENT

Transparency with Ethical Responsibility

The Journal of Indonesian Digital Islamic Studies (JIDIS), published by CV Zamzami Scholar Publishing, is committed to promoting research transparency, data integrity, methodological accountability, reproducibility where applicable, and responsible data sharing. This policy establishes standards for managing, preserving, accessing, and verifying research data supporting published findings.

Informed by the FAIR Data Principles and established scholarly publishing practices, JIDIS recognizes that research transparency must be balanced with participant privacy, confidentiality, intellectual property rights, and the ethical responsibilities associated with studying religious communities and digitally mediated practices.

01 / TRANSPARENCY

Verifiable Research

Supporting evidence should be sufficiently documented to enable scholarly assessment.

02 / ACCESSIBILITY

Responsible Data Access

Research data should be accessible wherever ethical and legal conditions permit.

03 / INTEGRITY

Ethical Data Stewardship

Data management must respect confidentiality, participant rights, and research integrity.

01

Research Data Transparency

Authors are responsible for ensuring that research data are accurate, appropriately documented, and obtained through lawful and ethically acceptable procedures.

Research data in digital Islamic studies may include interview transcripts, survey datasets, digital ethnographic observations, social media posts and comments, digital Qur'anic and hadith corpora, online religious discourse, platform-generated information, archival materials, and computational outputs.

Authors must provide sufficient information about data sources, selection criteria, collection procedures, analytical methods, and relevant limitations to enable independent scholarly assessment. Where relevant, the provenance, authenticity, and contextual integrity of religious texts and digital materials must be verified.

02

Data Availability Statement

JIDIS requires every original research article to include a Data Availability Statement specifying whether and how the data supporting its findings can be accessed.

The statement must identify relevant datasets or research materials, their location, applicable access conditions, and any restrictions on sharing. Where data are deposited in a repository, authors should provide a persistent identifier, preferably a DOI.

For conceptual, theoretical, hermeneutical, or other studies that do not generate or analyze new empirical datasets, authors must explain why data sharing is not applicable.

Editorial Requirement

A Data Availability Statement is required for every original research article, including studies involving restricted data or no new empirical datasets.

03

Data Sharing and Repositories

JIDIS strongly encourages authors to make supporting research data publicly accessible whenever ethically, legally, and practically feasible. Public deposition is encouraged but is not universally mandatory.

Authors may deposit datasets in recognized repositories, including Zenodo, Harvard Dataverse, the Open Science Framework (OSF), or appropriate institutional repositories. Shared materials should include sufficient metadata, documentation, and applicable licensing information to support interpretation, verification, and reuse.

INTERNATIONAL DATA STANDARDS

FAIR Data Principles

FFindable
AAccessible
IInteroperable
RReusable

JIDIS supports data stewardship consistent with the FAIR principles, while recognizing that accessibility may involve controlled or restricted access rather than unrestricted public disclosure.

Data Sharing Principle

Legitimate ethical, legal, confidentiality, intellectual property, and platform-related restrictions must be respected.

04

Privacy, Confidentiality, and Restricted Data

JIDIS recognizes that digital Islamic studies may involve identifiable social media users, religious communities, confidential interviews, sensitive religious expressions, private digital communications, and restricted institutional or platform data.

Authors must not disclose identifiable participant information, private communications, or restricted third-party materials without appropriate authorization and an applicable ethical or legal basis.

Public availability of digital content does not automatically eliminate ethical obligations concerning participant privacy, contextual integrity, or potential harm arising from republication or data aggregation.

Where unrestricted sharing is inappropriate, authors must explain the restrictions in their Data Availability Statement. Anonymized datasets, aggregated results, redacted materials, or controlled-access arrangements may be considered where ethically appropriate.

05

Data Preservation and Editorial Verification

Authors are expected to preserve research data and supporting documentation in accordance with institutional requirements, funding agreements, applicable law, and recognized disciplinary practices.

The editorial team may request underlying datasets, analytical documentation, coding frameworks, source records, or other relevant materials when necessary to assess methodological reliability, verify findings, or investigate research integrity concerns.

Such requests remain subject to ethical, legal, and confidentiality restrictions. Where direct access is prohibited, authors may be asked to provide an appropriate alternative means of verification.

Failure to provide reasonable clarification or supporting evidence without adequate justification may affect editorial decisions or initiate further investigation under the journal's publication ethics procedures.

06

Author Responsibilities and Compliance

Authors are responsible for the accuracy, integrity, lawful use, and appropriate documentation of research data submitted to JIDIS.

  • Accurately disclose the availability and accessibility of supporting data.
  • Acknowledge original data sources and respect third-party ownership and licensing conditions.
  • Ensure consistency between reported findings and underlying evidence.
  • Document data selection, coding, interpretation, and analytical procedures.
  • Protect participants' identities and comply with relevant ethical requirements.
  • Provide analytical code, coding frameworks, or processing documentation where appropriate and permissible.

For studies employing netnography, digital discourse analysis, computational text analysis, or other digitally mediated methods, authors should document sampling decisions, observation periods, analytical categories, and procedures for interpreting digital materials.

JIDIS reserves the right to request clarification, corrections, or supporting documentation where concerns arise regarding data reliability, accessibility, or integrity.

07

Recommended Data Availability Statements

Authors should select or adapt the following statements to reflect their actual research circumstances. Statements must not imply access that cannot be provided.

A

Publicly Available Data

"The datasets supporting the findings of this study are publicly available in [Repository Name] at [DOI or URL]."

B

Data Available upon Reasonable Request

"The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request, subject to applicable ethical and legal restrictions."

C

Restricted or Confidential Data

"The research data are not publicly available because they contain confidential or potentially identifiable information concerning research participants or religious communities."

D

Data Included in the Article

"All data supporting the findings of this study are included in the article and its supplementary materials."

E

No New Empirical Data

"No new empirical datasets were generated or analyzed in this study. Data sharing is therefore not applicable."

08

Policy Implementation

Authors must include a Data Availability Statement in every original research manuscript before publication. The editorial team may request revisions to statements that are incomplete, inconsistent, or insufficiently transparent.

JIDIS encourages responsible data sharing while recognizing legitimate restrictions arising from research ethics, participant confidentiality, intellectual property, platform conditions, and applicable law.

This policy supports scholarly accountability, methodological transparency, and confidence in published research on Islam, digital technologies, and contemporary Muslim societies.

RESEARCH DATA GOVERNANCE

Policy References and Standards

01

Springer Nature. Research Data Policy. Official Policy

02

Springer Nature. Data Availability Statements. Author Guidance

03

Wilkinson, M. D., et al. (2016). The FAIR Guiding Principles for Scientific Data Management and Stewardship. Scientific Data, 3, 160018. View Publication

JIDIS EDITORIAL COMMITMENT

Verifiable Research. Responsible Sharing.

Strengthening scholarly accountability without compromising research participants, confidential information, or ethical obligations.