Artificial Intelligence Usage Policy
Artificial Intelligence Usage Policy
Responsible, transparent, and accountable use of artificial intelligence in scholarly research and academic publishing.
Technology May Assist Scholarship. Accountability Remains Human.
The Journal of Indonesian Digital Islamic Studies (JIDIS), published by CV Zamzami Scholar Publishing, recognizes the potential of artificial intelligence (AI) to support scholarly research, academic writing, and publishing processes. However, AI use must not compromise research integrity, originality, methodological rigor, confidentiality, or human accountability. All scholarly claims, interpretations, and editorial decisions remain the responsibility of qualified human contributors.
Transparency
Disclose substantive AI assistance.
Human Accountability
Maintain responsibility for scholarly claims.
Research Integrity
Protect originality, accuracy, and rigor.
Confidentiality
Safeguard unpublished and sensitive information.
Purpose and General Principles
This policy establishes the requirements governing AI use by authors, peer reviewers, editors, editorial board members, and journal personnel throughout manuscript preparation, research reporting, peer review, and editorial management.
JIDIS recognizes that AI-assisted technologies, including generative AI systems and large language models (LLMs), may support language editing, literature exploration, coding, data processing, and visualization. Their use must remain transparent, critically verified, and consistent with applicable research ethics and publication standards.
Definition and Scope of AI Tools
AI tools include systems that generate, transform, classify, analyze, summarize, translate, or process textual, numerical, visual, audio, and other forms of information.
This policy applies to research design, data collection, processing, analysis, interpretation, manuscript preparation, peer review, editorial assessment, and publication production. Conventional spell-checking, basic punctuation correction, and standard reference-management functions generally do not require disclosure.
Acceptable and Unacceptable Uses of AI
Responsible and Verified Assistance
- Correcting language, grammar, and punctuation.
- Improving clarity and readability of author-written text.
- Translating material with human verification.
- Exploring literature and organizing preliminary searches.
- Supporting outlining and preliminary conceptual development.
- Assisting with coding, statistical analysis, and transparent data processing.
- Creating clearly identified conceptual illustrations.
- Identifying possible methodological or analytical limitations.
Practices That Compromise Integrity
- Fabricating or falsifying research data and evidence.
- Generating fictitious citations, references, or quotations.
- Presenting unverified AI-generated conclusions as established findings.
- Submitting arguments authors cannot substantiate or defend.
- Concealing plagiarism or copyright infringement.
- Manipulating figures or images to misrepresent evidence.
- Using unverified outputs or concealing substantive AI assistance.
Disclosure Requirements for Authors
Authors must disclose substantive AI assistance affecting manuscript content, research design, analytical procedures, interpretation, or presentation. Disclosure is required when AI is used to:
- Generate, rewrite, translate, or substantially restructure manuscript content.
- Synthesize literature incorporated into scholarly arguments.
- Generate or materially modify figures and illustrations.
- Develop research code or conduct substantive data processing.
- Classify, analyze, or interpret research data.
- Influence research design or methodological decisions.
Disclosures should identify the AI tool, provider, model or version where available, purpose, scope of use, and extent of human verification. Authors must disclose relevant AI use at submission and update the declaration during revision.
Placement and Format of AI Disclosures
Substantive writing, translation, or manuscript restructuring assistance must be declared in the acknowledgments or a separate declaration section before the references.
AI use in research design, data collection, coding, analysis, or interpretation must be explained in the Methods section, with sufficient detail to assess methodological transparency, reproducibility, and limitations.
AI-generated or materially modified figures must be identified in the relevant captions or accompanying declarations. Such materials must not be misrepresented as authentic empirical observations or unaltered records.
Suggested Disclosure Statements
"During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used [tool and model] developed by [provider] for [purpose]. All outputs were reviewed and verified by the authors, who take full responsibility for the manuscript's content."
"AI-assisted technology [tool and model] was used for [research procedure]. The authors independently evaluated the outputs and remain responsible for all analytical decisions, interpretations, and conclusions."
"Figure [number] was developed with assistance from [tool and model] for [purpose]. The authors verified its accuracy and appropriate representation."
"The authors declare that no generative AI or AI-assisted technologies were used beyond routine spelling, grammar, and punctuation checking."
Authors' Responsibilities and AI Authorship
Authors remain fully responsible for all submitted content, including AI-assisted text, translations, analysis, figures, and references. They must independently verify factual claims, citations, quotations, and bibliographic records against original sources, evaluate possible bias, respect intellectual property rights, and document substantive AI use.
In digital Islamic studies, particular care is required when AI processes Qur'anic verses, hadith texts, translations, religious rulings, or interpretive traditions. Authors must verify textual attribution, source authenticity, contextual accuracy, and interpretive claims against authoritative and traceable sources.
AI Tools Cannot Be Authors or Co-Authors.
Authorship is reserved for human contributors who can approve the final manuscript, accept scholarly responsibility, disclose competing interests, and respond to research integrity concerns.
Use of AI by Peer Reviewers
Peer reviewers must preserve manuscript confidentiality and exercise independent scholarly judgment. They must not upload, transmit, or disclose unpublished manuscripts, reviewer reports, or confidential correspondence to external AI systems unless the journal expressly authorizes the specific use and appropriate confidentiality, data protection, and intellectual property safeguards are in place.
Reviewers must not delegate substantive manuscript evaluation to AI. Where limited AI assistance is authorized, reviewers remain accountable for their assessments and must disclose substantive assistance to the handling editor.
Use of AI by Editors and Editorial Personnel
Editors and journal personnel must protect confidential submissions, reviewer identities, editorial correspondence, and unpublished research. External AI systems may be used only when specifically authorized and subject to appropriate safeguards.
AI may assist with limited editorial or administrative tasks but must not autonomously determine manuscript acceptance, rejection, reviewer credibility, research misconduct, or final editorial decisions.
Editors remain responsible for assessing scholarly quality, selecting reviewers, interpreting review reports, ensuring fair communication, and preserving editorial independence. The journal will provide appropriate transparency regarding substantive AI use in its editorial workflows.
Research Data, Privacy, and Intellectual Property
Authors must ensure that AI use respects research participants' rights, confidentiality, copyright, institutional requirements, and applicable data protection obligations.
Particular care is required when research involves social media interactions, digital religious communities, identifiable participant information, unpublished interviews, religious organizational records, or proprietary platform data.
Before transferring research materials to AI systems, authors must assess applicable privacy policies, data retention practices, security protections, informed consent, and permitted uses of submitted information. Confidential or identifiable data must not be uploaded where such disclosure is prohibited.
Editorial Assessment and Suspected Misuse
JIDIS may assess disclosed or suspected inappropriate AI use as part of its editorial and publication ethics responsibilities. Where concerns arise, the editorial team may:
- Request clarification or additional disclosure.
- Seek supporting documentation and source verification.
- Require correction of inaccurate or misleading material.
- Consult independent experts where necessary.
- Reject manuscripts with serious unresolved integrity concerns.
- Initiate an investigation under the journal's publication ethics procedures.
Non-Compliance, Corrections, and Appeals
Failure to comply with this policy may result in proportionate editorial action, including requests for clarification, additional disclosure, manuscript correction, rejection, expression of concern, retraction, or institutional referral, depending on the seriousness and consequences of the violation.
AI use alone does not constitute grounds for rejection or retraction. Editorial action must be based on demonstrable concerns involving misrepresentation, fabrication, plagiarism, compromised research validity, infringement of rights, or other material ethical violations.
Authors may appeal a decision by submitting a written explanation and supporting evidence to the Editor-in-Chief. Appeals will be handled according to the journal's established procedures. Where a relevant conflict exists, an independent editorial representative will assess the appeal.
Policy Implementation and Review
This policy will be reviewed periodically to reflect developments in AI technologies, scholarly publishing, research ethics, and data governance.
Authors, reviewers, editors, and journal personnel are expected to understand and comply with these requirements. Substantive policy updates will be published on the journal website.
Ethical Framework and References
This policy is informed by international guidance on responsible AI use in scholarly publishing.
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Authorship and AI Tools. COPE Resources
- COPE. Core Practices. View Guidelines
- International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work. View Recommendations
- World Association of Medical Editors (WAME). Recommendations on Chatbots and Generative Artificial Intelligence in Scholarly Publications. WAME Resources
- International Association of Scientific, Technical and Medical Publishers (STM). Recommendations for a Classification of AI Use in Academic Manuscript Preparation (2025). STM Resources
- Elsevier. Generative AI Policies for Journals. Elsevier Resources
Innovation with Integrity.
Responsible technology. Transparent scholarship. Human accountability.