JIDIS / EDITORIAL GOVERNANCE

Research Ethics & Ethical Oversight

Upholding responsible research conduct, participant protection, ethical accountability, and scholarly integrity in digital Islamic studies.

INTEGRITY · RESPONSIBILITY · ACCOUNTABILITY
01 / POLICY OVERVIEW

Ethical Research. Responsible Scholarship.

The Journal of Indonesian Digital Islamic Studies (JIDIS) is committed to ensuring that all submitted and published research complies with recognized ethical principles, professional standards, and applicable institutional and legal requirements. Particular attention is given to studies involving human participants, Muslim communities, religious identities, digital platforms, personal information, and sensitive religious materials.

FOUNDATIONAL FRAMEWORK

Core Ethical Principles

01

Respect for Persons

Protecting dignity, autonomy, and participant rights.

02

Beneficence

Maximizing benefits and minimizing foreseeable harm.

03

Justice and Fairness

Ensuring equitable and nondiscriminatory treatment.

04

Integrity and Honesty

Maintaining accuracy, transparency, and methodological rigor.

05

Privacy and Confidentiality

Safeguarding identities and sensitive research materials.

06

Responsible Data Governance

Managing research data ethically and securely.

01

Ethical Approval and Institutional Oversight

Research requiring ethical review must obtain approval from an appropriate research ethics committee, institutional review board, or equivalent body before the relevant research activities begin.

Authors must disclose the approving committee, institution, approval reference number, date, and relevant conditions, where applicable. Where ethical review is formally exempted, authors must explain the basis for exemption and provide supporting documentation when available.

Editorial Requirement Ethical approval or exemption must be reported accurately wherever required. Institutional approval does not eliminate the authors' continuing ethical responsibilities.
02

Research Involving Human Participants

Studies involving interviews, surveys, focus groups, participant observation, digital ethnography, or other human-centered methods must protect participants' dignity, autonomy, privacy, safety, and well-being.

Research procedures must avoid coercion, exploitation, discrimination, and unnecessary harm. Additional safeguards are required where participants are vulnerable because of age, dependency, social disadvantage, religious stigma, or other circumstances.

03

Informed Consent and Consent to Publication

Authors must obtain voluntary and appropriately documented informed consent where required. Participants should understand the research purpose, procedures, foreseeable risks, and intended use of their information.

Separate consent to publication must be obtained where required for identifiable quotations, photographs, recordings, or other materials that may reveal participant identities.

Important Ethical Distinction Consent to participate in research does not automatically constitute consent to publish identifiable information.
04

Ethics in Digital Islamic Research

JIDIS recognizes the distinctive ethical challenges of studying digital religious practices, online Muslim communities, digital da'wah, Qur'anic interpretation, hadith discourse, religious influencers, and networked religious identities.

Digital Ethnography
Social Media Research
Online Religious Communities
Digital Qur'anic and Hadith Discourse
Religious Identity and Representation
AI and Algorithmic Religious Systems

Public accessibility does not automatically authorize unrestricted collection, identification, republication, or reuse of digital content. Authors must assess reasonable expectations of privacy, contextual sensitivity, platform conditions, potential identifiability, and foreseeable risks to individuals or religious communities.

DIGITAL RESEARCH ETHICS

Public Data Still Require Ethical Judgment.

Ethical decisions must consider context, participant vulnerability, and the possible consequences of reproducing digital traces.

05

Privacy, Confidentiality, and Data Protection

Authors must protect personal information, confidential communications, research records, and sensitive religious data. Appropriate safeguards include anonymization or pseudonymization, secure storage, restricted access, and prevention of indirect identification.

Confidential interviews, private community discussions, unpublished religious documents, and restricted platform data must not be disclosed without appropriate authorization. Data handling must comply with applicable ethical and legal requirements.

06

Research Integrity and Responsible Reporting

JIDIS requires accurate methodological reporting, transparent analytical decisions, honest presentation of findings, and responsible interpretation of research evidence.

Fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, deceptive manipulation, unauthorized data use, and misrepresentation of research findings are prohibited. Authors must disclose relevant funding, conflicts of interest, and substantive AI assistance in accordance with the journal's applicable policies.

07

Ethical Responsibilities of Authors

Authors are responsible for:

  • Obtaining ethical approval or exemption where required.
  • Securing informed consent and publication consent where applicable.
  • Protecting participant rights, privacy, and confidentiality.
  • Obtaining permission to use restricted or third-party materials.
  • Reporting research methods and ethical safeguards accurately.
  • Disclosing ethical limitations and relevant protocol deviations.
  • Retaining appropriate compliance documentation and cooperating with reasonable editorial verification.

All co-authors share responsibility for the ethical integrity of the submitted work.

08

Editorial and Peer Review Ethical Oversight

The Editor-in-Chief and editorial team assess ethical compliance during manuscript evaluation. They may examine approval declarations, request supporting documentation, review consent and data protection statements, or seek independent expert advice.

Editorial processing may be suspended while significant ethical concerns are investigated. Ethical approval alone does not guarantee that every aspect of a study meets the journal's research ethics requirements.

09

Ethical Misconduct and Editorial Actions

Allegations of ethical misconduct will be assessed fairly, confidentially, and on the basis of available evidence.

01 Request for clarification
02 Supporting documentation
03 Suspension of editorial processing
04 Manuscript rejection where justified
05 Correction or expression of concern
06 Retraction where warranted

Editorial responses must be proportionate to the seriousness of the concern and consistent with the journal's publication ethics procedures.

10

Policy Implementation and Review

This policy applies to all manuscripts submitted to JIDIS and all research published by the journal. Authors must review its requirements before submission.

The journal may periodically update this policy in response to developments in research ethics, digital scholarship, data governance, and relevant regulations. Specialized research subject to additional ethical regulation must comply with applicable institutional and legal standards.

REFERENCE FRAMEWORKS

Research Ethics and Integrity

This policy is informed by recognized international frameworks for research integrity and ethical scholarly publishing.

01

Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Core Practices: Ethical Oversight. View Framework

02

Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing. COPE Resources

03

ALLEA. The European Code of Conduct for Research Integrity, Revised Edition 2023. View Code

JIDIS EDITORIAL COMMITMENT

Integrity Beyond Compliance.

Ethical research requires continuous responsibility, transparent reporting, and independent scholarly judgment.