JIDIS / EDITORIAL GOVERNANCE / PUBLICATION INTEGRITY
 

Article Withdrawal, Retraction & Correction

Transparent editorial procedures for protecting the integrity, reliability, and continuity of the scholarly record.

INTEGRITY · FAIRNESS · TRANSPARENCY
POLICY OVERVIEW

Protecting the Scholarly Record.

The Journal of Indonesian Digital Islamic Studies (JIDIS), published by CV Zamzami Scholar Publishing, is committed to maintaining the integrity, transparency, and reliability of scholarly communication. When substantial errors, publication misconduct, or serious legal and ethical concerns arise, appropriate editorial action may be necessary.

This policy establishes procedures for manuscript withdrawal, article correction, retraction, Expressions of Concern, exceptional removal, and republication. Decisions are based on documented evidence, proportionality, procedural fairness, and editorial independence.

Core Editorial Principle Published articles form part of the scholarly record. Corrections and editorial notices should preserve the publication history rather than obscure it.
EDITORIAL ACTION FRAMEWORK

Six Forms of Editorial Action

01 / PRE-PUBLICATION

Withdrawal

Removal of a manuscript from the editorial process before formal publication.

02 / POST-PUBLICATION

Correction

Transparent amendment of errors that do not invalidate the principal findings.

03 / POST-PUBLICATION

Retraction

Formal identification of published work as unreliable or seriously compromised.

04 / INVESTIGATION

Expression of Concern

Notification of serious unresolved questions about published research.

05 / EXCEPTIONAL CASES

Removal

Restriction of public full-text access for compelling legal, ethical, or safety reasons.

06 / REASSESSMENT

Republication

Publication of a substantially corrected and independently reassessed version.

01

General Principles

JIDIS follows recognized principles of publication ethics, including guidance issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the National Information Standards Organization (NISO).

Editorial action must be supported by credible evidence and proportionate to the seriousness of the identified concern. Authors will ordinarily be given an opportunity to respond before a final decision, except where immediate action is necessary to prevent significant harm.

Publication Status Matters Withdrawal generally concerns manuscripts before formal publication. Corrections, retractions, and other post-publication notices concern articles already forming part of the scholarly record.
02

Withdrawal of Manuscripts Before Publication

Manuscript withdrawal applies to submissions undergoing editorial processing or accepted for publication but not yet formally published.

Withdrawal may be considered when substantial errors cannot be resolved through revision, simultaneous submission or duplicate publication is identified, authorship information is materially inaccurate, or credible evidence of serious publication misconduct emerges.

Authors requesting withdrawal must submit a written explanation to the editorial office and confirm the agreement of all co-authors. Requests submitted after acceptance are subject to editorial assessment and are not automatically approved.

Previously Accessible Manuscripts If an accepted manuscript or article in press has already been publicly accessible, JIDIS may retain a withdrawal notice and relevant bibliographic records.
03

Correction of Published Articles

A correction may be issued when a published article contains an error that requires clarification or amendment but does not fundamentally invalidate its principal findings, arguments, or conclusions.

Correctable errors may involve inaccurate bibliographic information, author affiliations, data presentation, quotations, source attribution, methodological descriptions, or other substantive details.

In digital Islamic studies, corrections may also address inaccurate Qur'anic references, hadith citations, translations, or misidentified digital research materials, provided the underlying scholarly argument remains reliable.

CORRECTION PRINCIPLE

Correct Errors Without Concealing the Record.

Substantive corrections should be documented through an identifiable notice linked to the original article. Silent changes affecting scholarly interpretation are not permitted.

The correction notice should identify the original article, describe the error, state the correction, and indicate whether the main conclusions are affected. Relevant publication metadata will be updated where technically applicable.

04

Retraction of Published Articles

Retraction applies to formally published articles, including articles published online before assignment to a journal issue. It may be warranted when findings, evidence, or scholarly conclusions are substantially unreliable or serious publication ethics violations have occurred.

Plagiarism or substantial duplicate publication
Fabrication or falsification of research evidence
Serious authorship misconduct
Materially compromising undisclosed conflicts of interest
Serious violations of research ethics or participant rights
Errors invalidating principal findings or conclusions
Manipulated religious sources or fabricated digital research data

Retraction may be initiated by authors, editors, the publisher, or other parties presenting credible evidence. The editorial team may consult independent experts or relevant institutions where necessary.

Retraction Procedure
01Initial assessment of the reported concern.
02Opportunity for authors to respond and provide evidence.
03Independent consultation or institutional inquiry where appropriate.
04Editorial decision based on the available evidence.
05Publication of a formal, freely accessible retraction notice.
Retraction Notice Requirements

The notice will be titled "Retraction: [Original Article Title]" and identify the article, authors, publication details, DOI, and grounds for retraction. It will be published separately and linked directly to the original article.

The original article will ordinarily remain accessible with a prominent RETRACTED label. The PDF will carry a visible retraction watermark on each page, and relevant metadata will be updated where supported.

05

Expression of Concern

An Expression of Concern may be issued when credible evidence raises serious questions about a published article, but the available information is insufficient to justify immediate retraction.

This may occur when an investigation is ongoing, institutional findings are pending, or evidence remains inconclusive despite substantial concerns.

The notice will explain the concern without prejudging the outcome. It will be linked to the article and reviewed when additional information becomes available.

Important Distinction An Expression of Concern does not establish misconduct and is not equivalent to a retraction.
06

Article Removal in Exceptional Circumstances

Removal of published full-text content is an exceptional measure reserved for serious legal, ethical, privacy, or safety concerns.

Grounds may include unlawful disclosure of identifiable participant information, infringement of protected rights, legally mandated removal, or demonstrable risks to individuals or communities.

Removal will not ordinarily replace retraction or be used merely because an article contains errors or attracts scholarly disagreement.

Where legally permissible, JIDIS will retain the bibliographic record and replace the full text with a notice explaining the removal in appropriate terms.

07

Retraction and Republication

In exceptional circumstances, a retracted article may be considered for republication after substantial correction and reassessment.

Authors must explain the errors, document the revisions, and demonstrate that the corrected work provides a reliable scholarly account. Additional editorial evaluation or independent peer review may be required.

Republication is not automatic. The original article retains its retracted status, while the corrected version is published as a separately identifiable record linked to the original publication and its retraction notice.

08

Editorial Authority and Procedural Fairness

The Editor-in-Chief has ultimate responsibility for decisions concerning withdrawal, correction, retraction, Expressions of Concern, removal, and republication.

Decisions may be informed by handling editors, Editorial Board members, independent experts, or relevant institutions. Investigations must respect confidentiality, impartiality, procedural fairness, and the opportunity of concerned parties to respond.

Scholarly disagreement, alternative interpretations of Islamic texts, or differences in theoretical positions do not, by themselves, constitute grounds for retraction.

09

Documentation, Notification, and Metadata

JIDIS will maintain appropriate records of allegations, evidence, correspondence, editorial assessments, and final decisions.

Authors will ordinarily be notified of decisions affecting their work. Where appropriate, the journal may notify relevant institutions, indexing services, repositories, or DOI registration agencies.

Formal editorial notices will remain publicly identifiable and linked to the original article, with publication metadata updated where technically feasible.

10

Policy Implementation and Review

This policy applies to all manuscripts submitted to JIDIS and all articles published by the journal, regardless of publication date.

The editorial team may periodically review and update these procedures to reflect developments in publication ethics, scholarly communication, and digital publishing standards.

EDITORIAL FRAMEWORK

References and Standards

This policy is informed by internationally recognized guidelines for the communication of corrections, retractions, removals, and other editorial notices.

01
Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

COPE Retraction Guidelines.

Official Guidelines
02
National Information Standards Organization (NISO).

NISO RP-45-2024: Communication of Retractions, Removals, and Expressions of Concern (CREC).

Official Standard
03
Crossref.

Documentation on corrections, retractions, and publication relationships.

Crossref Documentation
JIDIS EDITORIAL COMMITMENT

Correct the Record. Preserve Its History.

JIDIS is committed to transparent editorial decisions, responsible publication practices, and the continuing integrity of scholarly communication.

JIDIS